Pie , 1 Each, $3.99
Freshly Baked
Pies
View all (23)Apple Pie, Old Fashioned, 4 Ounce, $1.49
Old Fashioned Apple Pie, 4 oz
Cyrus O'Leary's Chocolate Cream Pie, 7 Ounce, $4.49
Cyrus O'Leary's Coconut Cream Pie, 7 Ounce, $4.49
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Banana, Cream Pie, 7 Ounce, $4.49
Cyrus O'Leary's Pies Banana Cream Pie, 7 oz Graham Crumb Bottom with Banana-Flavored Cream Filling, Finished with Creamy Whipped Topping and Dutch Crumble.
Cyrus O'Leary's Sour Cream Lemon Pie, 7 Ounce, $4.49
Fresh Bake Shop 1/2 Pie - Lemon Krunch, 10 Ounce, $3.49
Prepared Fresh In Store
Fresh Bake Shop Family Size Apple Pie - 10 Inch, 38 Ounce, $8.49
Baked Fresh in Store

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Apple Brown Betty, 9 Inch, 34 Ounce, $4.99
Baked Fresh in Store

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Apple, 8 Inch, 24 Ounce, $4.99
Baked Fresh in Store

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Coconut Custard, 8 Inch, 22 Ounce, $5.99
Baked Fresh in Store

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Pumpkin, 10 Inch, 38 Ounce, $8.49
Baked Fresh in Store

Fresh Bake Shop Pie - Sweet Potato Pie, 10 Inch, 40 Ounce, $8.49
Baked Fresh in Store

Old Fashion Foods Baked Sweet Potato Pie, 4 Ounce, $1.49

Old Fashioned Pie, Cherry, 4 Ounce, $1.49
Old Fashioned Cherry Pie, 4 oz

Old Fashioned Pie, Lemon, 4 Ounce, $1.49
Old Fashioned Lemon Pie, 4 oz

Muffins & Scones
View all (11)Fresh Bake Shop Wild About Cranbery Orange Muffins, 1 Each, $5.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 4
Bake Shop Muffin - Banana Nut, 1 Each, $1.99
Café Valley Bakery Mini Muffins, Banana Nut, 10 Ounce, $2.99
Café Valley Bakery Banana Nut Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz
Café Valley Bakery Mini Muffins, Blueberry, 10 Ounce, $2.99
Café Valley Bakery Blueberry Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz
Café Valley Bakery Mini Muffins, Bran, 10.5 Ounce, $2.99
Café Valley Bakery Bran Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz

Café Valley Bakery Mini Muffins, Chocolate Chip, 10 Ounce, $2.99
Café Valley Bakery Chocolate Chip Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz
Café Valley Bakery Mini Muffins, Corn, 10.5 Ounce, $2.99
Café Valley Bakery Corn Mini Muffins, 12 count, 10.5 oz
Fresh Bake Shop Holiday Shortbread, 6 Ounce, $1.99
Holiday Shaped Shortbread Cookies - Package of 6
Fresh Bake Shop Muffins - Cinnamon Chip, 6.25 Ounce, $1.99
Fresh Bake Shop Puffin Muffins - Blueberry, 4 Pack, 20 Ounce, $5.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 4

Cakes
View all (62)Fresh Bake Shop Canolli Cream - 7 inch, 32 Ounce, $16.99
Pre-Packaged Cake

Bakery Fresh Italian Cream Cake, 1 Each, $36.99
7-Inch, Hand Made
Bowl & Basket Cheesecake New York Style, 16 Ounce, $8.99
Bowl & Basket New York Style Cheesecake, 16 oz
Bowl & Basket Cheesecake New York Style, 40 Ounce, $16.99
Bowl & Basket New York Style Cheesecake, 40 oz
Bowl & Basket Cheesecake Variety Sampler, 16 Ounce, $9.99
New York Style, Chocolate Marble, Strawberry Swirl & Mississippi Mud
Bowl & Basket Cheesecake Variety Sampler, 40 Ounce, $18.99
New York Style, Strawberry Swirl, Mississippi Mud, Chocolate Marble, Raspberry Swirl, Turtle
Bowl & Basket Lemon with Blueberry Glaze, Cheesecake, 16 Ounce, $8.99
Bowl & Basket Lemon Cheesecake with Blueberry Glaze, 16 oz
Bowl & Basket New York Style Cheesecake Slices, 6 Ounce, $3.99
Bowl & Basket New York Style Cheesecake Slices, 6 oz
Café Valley Bakery Cake , Lemon Streusel, 28 Ounce, $7.49
Café Valley Bakery Lemon Streusel Cake, 26 oz
Café Valley Bakery Cake, 7UP Naturally Flavored Lemon Lime, 1 Each, $7.99
Café Valley Bakery 7UP Naturally Flavored Lemon Lime Cake, 26 oz
Café Valley Bakery Cake, Louisiana Crunch, 26 Ounce, $7.99
Café Valley Bakery Louisiana Crunch Cake, 26 oz
Carvel Ice Cream Cake - Celebration, 75 Fluid ounce, $29.99
Layers of chocolate and artificially flavored vanilla ice cream with chocolate flavored crunchies and creamy whipped frosting.Serves 15-20.
Carvel Ice Cream Cake - Lil' Love, 5.13 Pound, $13.99
Layers of chocolate and artificially flavored vanilla ice cream with chocolate flavored crunchies and creamy whipped frosting. Serves 5-7.
Carvel Ice Cream Cake Cookie Dough, 32 Fluid ounce, $16.99
Layers of Chocolate and Naturally & Artificially Flavored Vanilla Ice Cream with Cookie Dough Pieces, a Layer of Chocolate Flavored Crunchies, Topped with Chocolate Drizzle, Cookie Dough Pieces, Chocolate Chips, & Creamy Whipped Icing
Celebrate Cake, Confetti Fudge Ice Cream, 36 Ounce, $13.99
Celebrate Confetti Fudge Ice Cream Cake, 36 fl oz Vanilla and Chocolate Ice Cream with a Layer of Chocolate Crunch and Fudge in the Middle Topped with Creamy Whipped Icing. Birthdays, half-birthdays, becoming a big brother, becoming a big sister, religious event, losing a tooth, getting a new tooth, learning to swim, getting a new bike, first day of school, last day of school, acing a test, PTA meeting, music recital, good report card, engagement, winning a playoff, winning the lottery, finding $10, getting your drivers license, graduating from anything, arriving from a road trip, bon voyage, launching your boat, third date, saying your sorry, saying "i love you", first day of spring, first day of summer, cheer winter blues, daylight savings, first day off in a long time, garden party, painting party, buying a sports car, lifting someone's spirits, buying your first home, welcome home, moving day, welcome to the neighborhood, open house, block party, father's day, mother's day, kids' day, birth of a child, brand new boss, brand new career, relocating, retirement, grandparents' day, expecting company, girls' night out, boys' night out, family night, poker night, just because, no reason at all, fill in the blank!
Fresh Bake Shop 5 Inch Special Order Cake, 1 Each, $7.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - 5 Inch - Custom Decorating Available - Assorted Fillings - 24 Hour Advance Notice Needed
Fresh Bake Shop Boston Cream Cake, 30 Ounce, $8.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - 7 Inches - Bavarian Creme & Fudge Icing
Desserts
View all (53)Fresh Bake Shop Large Cannoli, 3 Ounce, $3.99
Prepared Fresh in Store
Dessert Shells, 5 Ounce, $2.99
Dessert Shells, 5 oz
Dutch Maid Bakery Cake - Carrot, 40 Ounce, $18.99

Fresh Bake Shop Apple Snail Danish, 6 Ounce, $3.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 2
Fresh Bake Shop Apple Turnovers, 4 ct., 12 Ounce, $5.49
Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 4

Fresh Bake Shop Blueberry Puff Pastry Bites, 10 Ounce, $3.49
Prepared Fresh In Store - Package of 15
Fresh Bake Shop Cherry Filled Chocolate Cake Whipped Topping, 84 Ounce, $2.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - 1/2 Sheet - Custom Decorating Available - 24 Hour Notice Needed
Fresh Bake Shop Cherry Filled Yellow Cake Chocolate Icing, 84 Ounce, $2.99
Prepared Fresh In Store - 1/2 Sheet - Custom Decorating Available - 24 Hour Notice Needed
Fresh Bake Shop Cherry Turnovers, 4 ct., 12 Ounce, $5.49
Prepared Fresh in Store - Package of 4

Fresh Bake Shop Chocolate Baby Cake, 15 Ounce, $9.49
Baked Fresh Daily
Fresh Bake Shop Chocolate Bar Cake, 30 Ounce, $16.99
Baked Fresh Daily
Fresh Bake Shop Chocolate Double Layer Cake, 18 Ounce, $18.99
Pre-Packaged 7-Inch Chocolate Cake

Fresh Bake Shop Chocolate Pudding Parfait Cup, 12 Ounce, $2.99
Prepared Fresh In Store
Fresh Bake Shop Cinnamon Coffee Cake, 14 Ounce, $5.49
Prepared Fresh In Store
Fresh Bake Shop Donut Holes - Vanilla Cake, 25 ct., 10 Ounce, $5.49
Prepared Fresh In Store - 7 Inches - Custom Decorating Available - 24 Hour Notice Needed

Fresh Bake Shop Donut Poppers, 25 Each, $5.49
25 ct. Plain Chocolate Donut Popper
Fresh Bake Shop Fudge Iced Brownies, 8 Pack, 15 Ounce, $4.99
Donuts
View all (4)Maplehurst Country Treats Glazed Yeast Raised Donut Hole Clusters, 8.5 Ounce, $1.99
4 Pack

Fresh Bake Shop Assorted Donut Holes, 3 Ounce, $2.99
Baked Fresh Daily
Maple Donuts Donuts, Glazed, 24 Ounce, $3.99
Maple Donuts Glazed Donuts, 12 count, 24 oz
Cookies
View all (12)Lofthouse Frosted Sugar Cookies, 13.5 Ounce, $3.99
10 count

Fresh Bake Shop Candy Kid's Cookies, 24 Ounce, $3.49
Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Chocolate Chip, 24 ct., 26 Ounce, $3.49
Baked Fresh Daily - Package of 24

Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Chocolate Chocolate Chip, 24 ct., 26 Ounce, $3.49
Baked Fresh Daily - Package of 24

Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Chocolate Chunk, 24 Pack, 30 Ounce, $6.99
Gourmet cookies baked fresh at your store.
Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Macadamia White Chocolate Chip, 24 Pack, 30 Ounce, $6.99
Gourmet cookies baked fresh at your store.
Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Oatmeal Raisin, 24 ct, 26 Ounce, $3.49
Baked Fresh Daily - Package of 24

Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Oatmeal Raisin, 24 Pack, 30 Ounce, $6.99
Gourmet cookies baked fresh at your store.
Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Peanut Butter, 24 ct., 26 Ounce, $3.49
Baked Fresh Daily - Package of 24

Fresh Bake Shop Cookies - Variety, 24 Pack, 30 Ounce, $6.99
Gourmet cookies baked fresh at your store.
Fresh Bake Shop Sugar Kid's Cookie, 24 Ounce, $3.49
24 Pack